Let’s say your company spent $10 million on sales incentives last year. What was the resulting uplift in revenue as a result of these...
Are you paying your salesforce to do what your business needs?
Profitable growth. Better customer relationships. Penetration of your products and services. Sustainable future revenues. These are likely priorities for your business. Do you pay your salesforce to deliver these outcomes?
Incentive plans have the ability to drive significant changes in salesforce behaviour. Despite this, most businesses invest considerable sums of money into sales commissions, bonuses and other forms of sales incentives without reviewing and interrogating what behaviour is being rewarded.
Businesses desire to improve profitability, but pay reps on total sales revenue. Businesses desire to improve customer retention, but sales reps are rewarded primarily for new logo sales. Businesses want to grow new / strategic products and services, but sales reps are paid on current products due to their inherent ease of sale.
As a result, businesses pay their sales teams to behave in a manner that is misaligned with their business needs.
Sales reps will sell what you pay them on.
1. Increase in Sales Revenue vs. Profitable Growth
A key example of this is that many incentive plans reward sales revenue irrespective of the profitability of that sale.
Let’s assume a business wants to improve its Gross Profit, and grow its customer base. It will typically pay reps on gross bookings.
A rep selling $1m of revenue at 15% discount may earn the same as a rep selling $1m at full price.
In this scenario, the business is paying for revenue to be sold, but is not actively incentivising profitable sales. It may meet its target for sales growth, but at the expense of profitability.
Businesses need to consider which measures of profitability they wish to drive (gross profit, minimum margin, specific products, etc) and reward those appropriately.
This may require additional measures to be incorporated into the sales compensation plan. However, this should only be to the extent that is appropriate and commensurate with the importance of those commercial objectives.
2. New Customer Growth vs. Customer Retention
A similar scenario can arise where businesses pay for sales reps to bring in new customers, but neglect to appropriately incentivise renewal of existing customers.
This is commonly seen in SaaS businesses, where reps may be paid on new logos, but there is little (or no) consideration of renewals or expanding current customer relationships.
As a result, sellers will drive their activities towards acquiring new customers, with less (if any) focus on expanding and building relationships with current customers.
Renewals of customers will then be left to the Customer Success team (who are presumably not incentivised to retain customers).
There should be appropriate mechanisms to reward new logos, renewals, and expansion of existing customers, depending on the business’ sales strategy. If the business is looking to improve customer retention, this should be reflected in the sales compensation plan.
3. Driving New Product Growth
Businesses will often develop and introduce new products / services to the market, and want to drive sales of those offerings.
However, they do not always create an effective incentive to encourage sellers to drive sales of the new offering.
For example, if a business introduces a new product and wishes to increase sales of that product into the market, it may expect reps to do this simply by virtue of it being introduced.
However, reps will typically focus on selling to customers they have pre-existing relationships with, and in areas of higher sales competency and propensity. As a result, the new product may not receive the traction that the business desires.
It may therefore be beneficial to introduce an incentive specific to the new product to drive increased sales. This can take the form of an increased commission rate or product incentive, for a defined period.
Importantly, such incentives should be targeted at driving incremental sales of the new product / service, rather than simply paying reps on sales that they would have made regardless.
4. Driving Collaboration
As business and customer needs become more complex, there is typically greater reliance on sales teams and other contributors to close sales.
However, many sales compensation plans reward individual sales performance and do not appropriately consider other sales contributors.
Where there are multiple contributors to a sale (e.g. Account Executives, Sales Engineers / Consultants, Channel, etc), if only one of these receives the sales credit, it may not incentivise the others to assist with the sale.
This can lead to infighting and disputes between sales colleagues, and slower time-to-close.
Businesses need to consider their crediting policies and ensure that appropriate credit and incentives are offered to sales contributors where relevant.
Again, the aim is to continue to drive individual accountability, without disincentivising collaboration to support the broader business.
5. Booking Sales vs. Sustaining Sales
Sales compensation plans will commonly pay on bookings / new business, with some conditions that need to be met before the commission is payable.
However, it is also common to see sales paid on bookings that may later be cancelled, and not appropriately managed within the incentive plan.
This can be particularly detrimental to the business, where reps are incentivised to drive sales towards the end of the quarter, which are subsequently cancelled.
Businesses should consider their cancellation / clawback policy, any eligibility conditions, and desired outcomes with customers to ensure the appropriate sales performance is being rewarded.
6. Quotas and Accelerators
Once a business has determined the measures it wants to incentivise, it must consider the appropriateness of its quota setting and commission accelerators.
Inappropriate quota setting and accelerators can result in sellers focusing their activity around these points. For example, selling heavily to hit the next accelerator threshold, or focusing on lower value deals where reps feel they cannot achieve quota.
Businesses need to carefully review the setting of quotas and accelerators to ensure appropriate sales performance is driven.
7. Ensure a continuous feedback loop between Sales Compensation and Business Strategy
Business strategy is continually changing. There will be new products to market, changes in customer behaviour, new territories and markets, and changes in profitability.
Sales Compensation plans need to be reviewed to ensure they are driving the required behaviours at all times. This should be a joint activity between Sales Compensation, Finance, HR and Sales Leadership, and consider the sales payouts and sales results being delivered.
Some examples of questions to consider:
a. Is your incentive plan paying on the right measures to drive your current business strategy?
b. Are you paying for profitable sales?
c. Is the appropriate emphasis being placed on new vs existing customer sales?
d. Are you driving the right level of focus to new products?
e. Do you want to incentivise collaboration between your sales teams?
f. Are your quotas / accelerators driving the desired sales behaviour?
Summary
The aim of the Sales Compensation plan is to ensure your salesforce are paid appropriately to drive your desired business outcomes.
If your sales compensation plan does not pay for the behaviours you desire, you will be paying out significant amounts of money to your sales team to drive behaviour that does not support your business strategy.
It is therefore imperative that Sales Compensation teams continually review and challenge their plans to ensure they are driving the desired sales behaviours.
If your sales team were to act purely in line with what they are paid to do, would this deliver the desired business outcomes for you?
The test of a sales compensation plan should be the quality of decisions being made by the salesforce as a result of it.
