As your business continues to grow and your sales force continues to expand. Will your Sales Compensation team be able to support this growth...
Are You Getting the Right Return on Your Sales Compensation Investment? Measuring the Effectiveness of Every Incentive Dollar
Let’s say your company spent $10 million on sales incentives last year. What was the resulting uplift in revenue as a result of these incentives?
Companies devote substantial capital to sales compensation in the pursuit of revenue. It is often one of the most significant sources of investment, spanning base commissions, variable payouts, accelerators, one-off incentives and sales strategies.
So what is the return on that investment?
Can you say with confidence that the revenue you paid your salesforce on was truly incremental as a result of the incentives you provided?
The majority of businesses today track Sales Compensation performance based on payout amounts, attainment levels, commission levels and variance to budget. However, this will not give you a clear indication of the return on incentive spend.
It will tell you the revenue achieved and that you have paid out the right commission amount, but not the incremental revenue and return on sales incentive spend.
We need to start to focus on measuring the returns from the investment that we put into our sales incentives.
1. Increased revenue is not enough
If your company achieved $100m in revenue last year and spent $10m on sales incentive, and you achieve $110m this year whilst paying out $11m in incentives, have you been successful?
Your revenue has grown by $10m, so presumably your sales compensation plans have been effective.
But is the increase in revenue truly due to your incentive plans, or was it achieved organically? Could it be due to external factors, new product offering, growth of existing customer base etc.?
You will have paid out incentives on $110m of revenue, but to what extent was that uplift generated by your sales incentives?
You need to be able to quantify and attribute the uplift to your incentive plans. As a Sales Compensation leader you should be seeking to understand the incremental revenue driven by your sales incentive spend.
2. Understand the incremental revenue generated by your sales incentive spend
As described above, you need to understand the incremental revenue achieved vs. some baseline or expected counter-factual.
If you have introduced a sales incentive on a new product offering that pays a further 2% commission on revenue generated from that product. Over the period of the sales incentive, the revenue generated by sales reps is $5m.
If you can establish through a reasonable comparison set (e.g. historical run rates, control set of comparable sales reps etc.) that $3m would have been generated absent of the sales incentive, then you can estimate $2m of incremental revenue generated.
If the delta in incentive payout for that is $200k, then you have an estimate of the incremental revenue and return on that sales incentive spend.
Clearly there will be caveats around your estimates, but it gives you a starting point for assessing the return on sales incentive spend, and avoids assuming that all of the $5m was generated due to the incentive.
There are many other factors to consider, including historic run rates, seasonality, territory/segment potential, peer set of sellers etc. when establishing the incremental revenue.
3. Assess return on sales incentive spend vs. gross profit
It is important to understand the revenue and gross profit generated by sales incentive spend. If you are driving more sales at a lower margin (e.g. increased discounts) or incurring higher cost to acquire a customer, is that a positive outcome for your business?
Assume that you have two sales reps. Rep 1 generates $2m in revenue at a 35% GP, and Rep 2 generates $2.5m in revenue at a 20% GP. Rep 2 is selling more, but Rep 1 is driving $0.7m of GP vs. $0.5m for Rep 2.
Therefore you should be considering how your sales incentive measures and payouts impact the behaviours of your sales reps and drive the desired outcomes for the business.
Ensure that you have a combination of metrics in your incentive plan to drive the behaviours and outcomes that are important to the business (e.g. GP, revenue from certain products/customers, retention, growth of key accounts, DSO/collections etc.).
The point is that you are paying for desired behaviours that are driving the outcomes that are important to your business.
4. Understand where your incentive spend is driving the greatest uplift
As described above, it is important to understand the return on your sales incentive spend. It is also beneficial to be able to establish where that return is highest and identify areas where you may be overspending.
For instance, you may find that your enterprise sales reps require accelerators to achieve uplift in performance, but your channel sales reps achieve a similar result without the need for incentive. Alternatively, you may find that a particular sales incentive drives a large uplift in sales of a product in one segment, but less in another.
You can therefore look to apply various metrics to assess sales incentive spend at different levels (e.g. sales rep, segment, business unit etc.), such as:
a. Incremental revenue vs. baseline expectation
b. Incremental GP vs. baseline expectation (net of incentive spend)
c. Incentive spend as % of revenue and GP
d. Return on incremental sales incentive spend
e. Sales performance across segments etc.
The aim is to understand where your sales incentive dollars are creating the greatest return to the business.
5. Look to optimise your sales incentive plans
Once you have established which sales incentives are effective and generating uplift to the business, you can use this to guide the design of future incentive plans.
For example, you may spend $2m on incentives to drive an increase in customer meetings. If you find that the number of meetings has increased significantly, but the subsequent pipeline and/or closed revenue is little changed, then clearly the sales incentive has not been effective in driving the desired outcome.
Rather than increase the level of spend, you should look to revisit the measures you are incentivising against (and any associated qualification rules, payout levels etc.) to better drive the behaviours and outcomes you are seeking from the business.
This should be an ongoing assessment as your incentive plans are updated.
6. Develop a management process to govern sales incentive spend
By following the points above, you should have the ability to understand the return on your sales incentive spend. You can then use this to establish a management process to monitor incentive spend against the associated business returns.
At the outset of implementing a significant sales incentive, you should agree the business objective, estimate the expected outcome in the absence of the incentive and target the desired incremental outcome.
You can then monitor the performance against that expectation and determine the ongoing return on the incentive.
You can also involve Finance in the process to drive a stronger linkage between sales incentive spend and returns. This is a natural extension of the partnership between Finance, Sales Ops and HR in managing Sales Compensation.
Final thoughts
The above are just some initial thoughts to drive a greater focus on the return on sales incentive spend. I think we need to start to evolve how we measure the return from our sales incentive spend and focus on incremental revenue, GP, seller behaviour and return on spend.
Rather than trying to reduce sales commissions, we should be seeking to better understand the link between incentive spend and the behaviours and outcomes we want to drive in the business.
So back to the original question: if your company spent $10m on sales incentives this year, can you confidently say how much incremental revenue and GP that has driven?
That is the key metric to understand the effectiveness of your Sales Compensation programme.
